Does anyone have any direct experience. hopefully a successful one, with dulling the finish on polished aluminum? I have quite a few parts that have been polished and I would really like to go back to a raw looking finish. 2 blowers, a set of aluminum TP heads, intakes and a couple SOHC timing covers.
I know painting will be the easiest process but was wondering if anyone had any tricks up their sleeves...?
I have weld repaired and cast many custom intake manifolds from scratch and have lots of experience trying to blend and match repairs on those and carburetors too. You can get a range of
color change including that which closely resembles as cast color but you'll find it's very difficult/never get the true as cast appearance back after polish. The color can range from very dull grey to bright aluminum depending upon the media. I never blast any surface exposed to the engine.
On small repairs I use the surface of a file and light hammer blows to stipple/texture the repaired area making it much more similar to that of the original cast surface, then media blast the entire intake to give it uniform color. It's tedious and would be totally impractical for an entire intake or blower. I've often thought that some crazy course media might come close but never been motivated enough to try to source such media or mod the blast gun to accommodate it.
The other thing to be aware of, the color will change over time as the blasted surface oxidizes. Finer medias usually age to be more grey and resemble the (clear) anodized color of commercial intakes. Often, a weld repaired area wont age color the same even though initially undetectable, but in most cases it's a very subtle difference. There are ways to make this coloring aging occur more quickly without actually anodizing.
Experienced and trained eyes will notice these things immediately, but once in an engine compartment.....lesser so. Knowing your business Jack, and given the effort/cost it takes to polish a blower or intake, I'd save those parts for those that want a polished part.
Best,
Klely