I'd be looking at a 3000+ stall speed converter, to get the engine up into the powerband on acceleration. The stall speed does not have to be lower than your cruise RPM; any slippage will be so small that it won't be noticeable at cruise speeds. On acceleration, when you mash the throttle the RPM will flash up to somewhere around the stall point; you want that to happen where the engine is starting to make really good power. Too low a stall speed will make the engine feel doggy when you mash the throttle. It took me a while to learn this; I was really worried about running a 4500 RPM stall converter in a 700 HP FE on the street back in 2005, but the car ran 2500 miles in a week during Drag Week that year, and was flawless on the road cruising at 2600 RPM. Now I'm comfortable running over 6000 RPM stall on the street, for a more radical engine.
Let a good converter company guide you, as Drew suggests.