A hydraulic roller lifter will always live longer (much, much, much longer) because they don't see the spring loads that a solid roller lifter sees and they don't have lash. The combination of lash and spring load is what makes a solid roller lifter fail.
A hydraulic roller lifter will pretty much live indefinitely.....think of how many 5.0 Mustangs and Explorers that have 100-200k miles on them.