I did that in an tank for the Falcon before I updated it to using a 15 gallon fuel cell. Pickup on the bottom of the sump using a cut down bulkhead fitting, and a return line through a similar fitting on top of the tank. The original pickup line was plugged. I can't comment on the mechanical pump because I haven't used one in 30 years. Electrics are all I run. I like them much better than any mechanical pump.